Published in tinku.es
Francisco Aguirre, Founding Partner of OC Asesores, has shared on Tinku Legal a clear and critical view of secondary liability proceedings (derivación de responsabilidad) for tax debts brought against former directors. His contribution sheds light on an issue of great concern among executives and business owners: can the tax authorities demand payment of tax debts from someone who no longer holds the position of director in a company?
The origin of the conflict: formalities and administrative negligence
Aguirre explains that the starting point for secondary liability proceedings is registration with the Commercial Registry. If a company does not update the information on its directors, the tax authorities may take action against the person who still appears as responsible, even if that person no longer performs any functions.
According to the expert, this situation is common and can have serious legal and financial consequences for former directors. In a recent case, OC Asesores obtained a decision from the Regional Economic-Administrative Court (TEAR) of Madrid annulling secondary liability proceedings for €150,000 brought against a former director.
The reversal of the burden of proof
One of the most alarming aspects Aguirre denounces is the tax authorities’ practice of reversing the burden of proof.
“The presumption of innocence goes out the window,” he states
As he explains, instead of the authorities having to prove that the director acted negligently or with intent (dolo), the person affected is required to show that he or she has not committed any infringement.
This conduct, which Aguirre describes in some cases as “malfeasance” (prevaricación), creates serious legal uncertainty. “What we’re saying is, look here, pay first and defend yourself afterward,” he protests, pointing out that this can ruin the lives of people who later turn out to be innocent.
An encouraging precedent from the TEAR and the Supreme Court
The case handled by OC Asesores was resolved favorably thanks to the intervention of the TEAR, which applied a recent Supreme Court judgment of May 20. That judgment establishes that it is the Spanish Tax Agency (AEAT) that must prove the director’s negligence before bringing secondary liability proceedings.
This judicial precedent introduces a fairer criterion and protects former directors who, although they did not record their departure from office in the Commercial Registry, can nonetheless show through documentary evidence that they left the position and that the debts arose under different management.
The key: documentation and registration
Aguirre insists that, to avoid these situations, it is crucial to leave formal evidence of the departure from office and to make sure that the departure is registered with the Commercial Registry.
“Signing the deed is not enough; it has to be officially published,” he stresses
He also recommends that former directors carefully check that no outstanding debts or irregular situations remain when they step down. Although this does not eliminate the risk, it may prove key in any future legal defense.
Criticism of the current revenue-collection model
The interview moves on to a broader critique of how the Tax Agency operates. Aguirre denounces “excessive aggressiveness” on the part of the tax authorities and an abusive use of taxpayers’ information. In his view, the authorities have acquired disproportionate power that turns citizens into permanent suspects.
“The problem is that there is no equality of position when you are being investigated,” he remarks, describing cases in which the tax authorities act knowing that their interpretation is wrong, yet force the taxpayer to appeal and to pay first.
“That’s called malfeasance,” he asserts emphatically
Penalties and covert extortion
Another worrying point Aguirre addresses is the penalty system. In his experience, more than 90% of the penalty proceedings his firm handles are annulled. Even so, many people pay out of fear or lack of knowledge.
He describes how the tax authorities offer reductions of up to 70% if the penalized person does not appeal and pays immediately, in what he calls “covert extortion.” This practice, although lawful, reinforces a system that puts revenue collection ahead of justice.
Practical recommendations for companies and executives
Aguirre concludes by underlining the need for constant, up-to-date tax advice. He warns that the regulatory environment is constantly changing and that what is correct today may be penalized tomorrow because of a change in administrative criteria.
He therefore recommends obtaining ongoing professional advice, reviewing past actions, and anticipating possible new interpretations by the tax authorities.
“It’s an excessive cost, but a necessary one to defend yourself in a hostile environment,” he states


