Published in confilegal.com
The Regional Economic-Administrative Court of Madrid (TEAR) has upheld a claim filed by the firm OC|Tax&Legal on behalf of a client to whom the Spanish Tax Agency (AEAT) sought to transfer a €150,000 tax debt owed by a company of which he was no longer a director.
The decision releases the individual concerned from all liability, finding that no breach whatsoever occurred during his time as director.
The dispute originated in secondary liability proceedings (derivación de responsabilidad) initiated by the AEAT against the former director of a commercial company. Although the termination of his directorship had been formalized in a public deed, the new director did not register that change with the Commercial Registry.
Relying on that failure to register, the tax authorities considered that the former director still held office and was therefore jointly and severally liable for the tax debts.
However, the Madrid TEAR has found in favor of the taxpayer, stressing that the fact that the termination had not been registered does not mean that it had not taken place.
In its decision, the court cites Supreme Court judgment (STS) 6469/2010, whose second legal ground establishes that the registration of a director’s termination is not constitutive in nature and that the termination may be proven by other means.
Specifically, in this case, a public deed evidencing both the termination and the new appointment was submitted, and this was considered sufficient proof.
Burden of proof
Furthermore, the court notes that, under Articles 105 et seq. of the General Tax Law (LGT), it is for the tax authorities to prove not only the objective facts on which the secondary liability is based, but also the subjective element, that is, that the person concerned breached his duties or allowed third parties to breach theirs.
In this regard, the TEAR concludes that the AEAT has proven neither, and therefore the debt cannot be attributed to the former director.
Francisco Aguirre, founding partner of OC|Tax&Legal, regards the decision as a significant victory for taxpayers’ rights, and stresses that “This case is a clear example of how the AEAT, on many occasions, presumes directors’ liability without sufficient evidence.”
Moreover, “the TEAR’s decision reaffirms that taxpayers have the right to defend themselves and to show that they are not liable for certain debts.”
For her part, Laura Esteban, associate at OC|Tax&Legal and responsible for defending the case, adds: “The case law is clear: registration of the termination with the Commercial Registry is not a constitutive requirement, and taxpayers are entitled to submit other evidence proving that they have severed their ties with the company. In this case, we succeeded in demonstrating that our client had properly ceased to hold office and could not be held liable for the debts incurred afterwards.”


